Showing posts with label Teams. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Teams. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 10, 2024

For Sale by Owner

Catherine Trammell - Contributing Reporter


Overall Cobbfather is a fantastic league will little turnover from season to season, but this coming S62 seems to be a little different. Owners are GREAT and the commish, even though he owns a team in Canada; does a great job catering to what the majority wants out of the league. That said, here are the teams for sale this season. 

  • Boston (AL)
    • A storied franchise that has only had two owners, the original owned the team the first 50 seasons and the most recent from S51 through S61; where he's put the team back on the block. He ended with a 865-917 record; making the wildcard twice (S55 & 58). 

    • We'll look further at their current roster in a bit but let's look at the competition.  The first one to mention should always be the Atlanta Expos, who own the most World Series rings in Cobbfather history and is on a historic run of Division titles. That said, Matty Moss and Kyle Crain - two of their main players over those titles are getting older. Augusta and New York are coming out of rebuilds so it might be the perfect time to start a rebuild under new ownership; with a goal to come out of the rebuild right around the time the others are starting to think about their next rebuild.  
    • Last season Records
      • ML: 77-85 (4th)
      • AAA: 94-50 (2nd)
      • AA: 84-60 (2nd)
      • A+: 101-43 (1st)
      • A-: 91-53 (1st)
      • R: 50-26 (2nd)
    • This is a decently young  team with some good pieces if you wanted to try and fire it up during Free Agent and bring in some missing pieces but also good if you want to go into sell mode for your own rebuild. Majority of the roster has less than 5 ML years of experience with only 4 players at or above the age of 31 and nobody over the age of 34. And little committed over the next few seasons. 
      • (ages are listed as of the upcoming season)
      • Guaranteed Salary 
        • Last season's payroll: $136M
        • S62: $23.6M
        • S63: $11.35M
        • S64: $0M
        • S65: $0M
      • Arbitration Class
        • Octavio Salas (26 yr old - RF) - Arb1
          • 30-45 HR, 30 SB, .280 hitter
        • Brook Page (27 yr old - SP) - Arb1
          • Acquired in S61
          • 94 starts, 32-35, 1.36 whip, 4.18 era
        • Marwin Despaigne (28 yr old - RP) - Arb1
          • 1.47 whip, 3.97 era
        • Willie Machado (29 yr old - 2B) - Arb2
          • 15 HR, 15-20 SB, .270 hitter
        • Alberto Castillo (29 yr old - CF) - Arb3
          • Used S61 as defensive replacement late in games
        • Kelvim Wilkinson (29 yr old - C) - Arb1
          • Defensive Catcher
        • Kenley Uribe (30 yr old - LF) - Arb2
          • Acquired in S61
          • 15 HR, 10 SB, .265 hitter
        • Floyd Syndergaard (30 yr old - RP) - Arb3
          • 1.40 whip, 4.40 era
        • Bubba Kennedy (31 yr old - SP) - Arb2
          • 158 starts, 63-49, 1.37 whip, 3.99 era
        • Ernie Gaetti (31 yr old - SP) - Arb3
          • 128 starts, 50-51, 1.44 whip, 4.66 era
        • Miguel Arencibia (32 yr old - P) - Arb3
          •  Long Relief, 1.46 whip, 4.71 era
        • Jerry Lansing (33 yr old - RP) - Arb2
          • 1.52 whip, 4.88 era
      • Contract Renewals
        • Willis Ruggiano (23 yr old 3B)
        • Mo Collins (25 yr old C)
        • Lonnie Loney (23 yr old CF)
        • Harry Roosevelt (27 yr old P)
        • Don Branson (28 yr old RP)
        • Franklin Robertson (27 yr old 1B)
        • Dave Nevin (26 yr old SP)
        • Butch Gibson (30 yr old P)
      • Existing Contracts (listed by length of contract)
        • Jim Randall (32 yr old - C) - expires after S63 - 2/$9.2M remains
          • 15 HR, 0 SB, .315 hitter
        • Wilking Alvarez (30 yr old - SP) - expires after S63 - 2/$13.6M remains
        • Efren Solis (31 yr old - SS) - expires after S62 - 1/$6M remains
          • 15 HR, 10 SB, .240 hitter (should platoon)
        • Alexander Sandberg (30 yr old - LF) - expires after S62 - 1/$6.3M
          • 25 HR, 10 SB, .275 hitter
      • Upcoming Free Agents
        • Only minor league players. 
      • Prospects
        • DH Calvin Yosida (S57 - #41 pick)
        • SP Glenallen McElroy (S59 - #23 pick)
        • SS Mack Shckleford (S59 - #56 pick)
        • RF Evan Hall (S60 - #20 pick)
        • RP Tony Blanco (S60 - #36 pick)
        • RP Rod Hull (S61 - #16 pick)
        • RP Wilmer Caballero (S61 - #58 pick)
        • SP Julian Ellis (S61 - #67 pick)

  • Mexico City (AL)
    • The commissioner's office and stripped ownership and put this team up for sale for failing to reach the minimum win requirement that was put into place just this season. Sad news for Mexico City fans as the new owner likely moves the team back to the states. Cerveza for all before they leave! Previous owner held the team since S53, and spent 38M+ for 7 straight seasons. He's been a huge trader within the league so many of his former trade partners will miss him. The team missed the MWR by a single W. A single W made all the difference, though it was looking bleak, a HUGE late season run made it close. The team won 90 and 92 games the last two seasons but it was the S61 off season decision to sell EVERYTHING that limited their ability to reach the MWR. They likely should have held on to at least one of the major pieces they traded away. 

    • We'll look further at their current roster in a bit but let's look at the competition. This has to be one of the toughest divisions in the league, with both Houston and Huntington generally ranking in the top 5 teams in the league. Jacksonville is the final team in the division and has a solid owner but like I said, it's a tough division. 
    • Last season Records
      • ML: 54-108 (4th)
      • AAA: 103-41 (1st)
      • AA: 113-31 (1st)
      • A+: 113-31 (1st)
      • A-: 102-42 (1st)
      • R: 45-31 (1st)
    • As its been mentioned this team sold way too much last season so they didn't reach the league minimum 55 wins and had to be replaced. Should be in pretty decent shape to hit whatever rebuild you want to do from the get go.  
      • (ages are listed as of the upcoming season)
      • Guaranteed Salary 
        • Last season's payroll: $37.4M
        • S62: $0M
        • S63: $0M
        • S64: $0M
        • S65: $0M
      • Arbitration Class
        • Vicente Pelaez (25 yr old - C) - Arb1
          • .265, 10 HR, 0 SB
        • David Almanzar (27 yr old - SS) - Arb1
          • .240, 5 HR, 3 SB
          • Slightly above average defensive ratings
        • Brock Hogan (29 yr old - RF) - Arb1
          • .245, 18 HR, 20 SB
        • Dale Miller (29 yr old - C) - Arb1
          • S61: .200, 2 HR, 3B
        • Hamish Coleman (31 yr old - SS) - Arb1
          • .200, 5 HR, 5 SB
          • Average SS ratings
        • Alcides Terrero (37 yr old - SP) - Arb1
          • S61: 39 games, 1.54 whip, 5.07 era
        • Dan Ford (29 yr old - P) - Arb1
          • Career: 105 starts, 1.24 whip, 3.66 era
            • Had a career worse S61 in 6 games. 
        • Hector Arnold (31 yr old - RP) - Arb2
          • S61: 73 games, 1.14 whip, 3.42 era
        • Hector Diaz (37 yr old - P) - Arb2
          • S61: 49 games, 1.49 whip, 5.11 era
      • Contract Renewals (listing major players)
        • Dan Ford (SP)
          • 32-29, 1.24 whip, 3.66 era
        • Marwin Villarreal (SP)
          • 14-16, 1.30 whip, 3.76 era
        • Junior Morris (LF)
          • .245, 12 HR, 25 SB
        • TJ Bowman (1B)
          • .240, 15 HR
        • David Almanzar (SS)
          • Glove first
        • Vic Martinez (CF)
          • Was promoted to try and get to 55 wins.
      • Existing Contracts (listed by length of contract)
        • None
      • Upcoming Free Agents
        • Akinori Yoshii (36 yr old - DH)
          • S61: .266, 5 HR, 1 SB
        • Omar Villano (31 yr old - LF)
          • S61: .285, 18 HR, 14 SB
        • Butch Womach (35 yr old - RP)
          • S61: 79 games, 1.38 whip, 3.72 era
      • Prospects
        • RP Kes Baines (S59 - #6 pick)
        • RP Allen Roberts (S59 - #8 pick)
        • RP Rosell Perez (S59 - #20 pick)
        • 2B Emmanuel Villalona (S59 - #22 pick)
        • C Arthur Howell (S59 - #40 pick)
        • RF Alfredo Reyes (S59 - $2.6M IFA)
        • P Juan Amaral (S59 - $4.7M IFA)
        • P Dilson Romero - (DITR)
        • P Will Wilkins (S60 #14 pick)
        • 3B Eduardo Guardado (S60 - $5.5M IFA)
        • SS Charles Martin (S60 - $22.5M IFA)
        • RP Onelki Johnson (S60 - $22.5M IFA)

  • Santa Fe (NL)
    • The previous owner actually took over the team mid-way through FA last season for Pokey (if you know him, he was in a ton of leagues and even commish of a few). If you don't know Pokey, he likes to build a big budget team, mostly through free agency. Well considering the replacement owner came in mid-way through FA; he didn't quite get to fill in the gaps had he started at the turn of the season. The replacement owner also prefers to build their team via draft and IFA, which is why the temp owner is not returning. But the team has won the division the last 3 seasons, even won the DCS last year (this year they were knocked out). If the big budget team is your thing, definitely take a look here. Still a solid team to build around if you ask me. 

    • We'll look further at their current roster in a bit but let's look at the competition. Charleston and Austin are similar teams and seem to be stuck. Both are committed to contending against you for the title but feel like a step behind you. New Orleans is the last team, and they've just entered a rebuild, so nothing to worry about there. 
    • Last season Records
      • ML: 94-68 (1st)
      • AAA: 82-62 (3rd)
      • AA: 76-68 (4th)
      • A+: 70-74 (4th)
      • A-: 80-64 (3rd)
      • R: 53-23 (1st)
    • If you generally build with a big budget team, this one is set for you. With the temp owner taking over mid way through FA last season, you have a lot of wiggle room incase you wanted to go the prospect rebuild route as well. 
      • (ages are listed as of the upcoming season)
      • Guaranteed Salary 
        • Last season's payroll: $104.6M
        • S62: $74M
        • S63: $58M
        • S64: $6M
        • S65: $0M
      • Arbitration Class
        • Kristopher Clarkson (28 yr old - LF) - Arb2
          • S59 & 60: All-Star, Gold Glove, Silver Slugger LF
          • .315avg, 30 hr, 20 sb
        • Wesley Bass (28 yr old RF) - Arb2
        • Bobby Ruebel (29 yr old - 2B) - Arb3
        • Don Chung (29 yr old - P) - Arb2
          • 25-19, 17/28 sv, 1.35 whip, 4.29 era
        • Gregory Briceno (30 yr old - SS) - Arb2
          • .235, 20 hr
        • Wiki Calderon (32 yr old - RP) - Arb2
          • 49-30, 1.37 whip, 4.54 era
        • Orlando Tomas (34 yr old - 2B) - Arb3
      • Contract Renewals
        • Braden Bassitt (26 yr old - LF)
          • S61 All-Star
          • .290, 25 HR, 50 SB
        • Edgard Silva (26 yr old - RF)
          • .250, 10 HR, 12 SB
        • Al Beaulac (27 yr old - 3B)
        • Edwards Barrett (27 yr old - SS)
        • Piper Ball (27 yr old - 2B)
          • .285, 12 HR, 12 SB
        • Efrain George (37 yr old - SP)
          • S61 Rookie of the Year (as a 36 yr old)
          • S61 3rd in NL Cy Young voting
          • 17-3, 1.24 whip, 3.24 era
      • Existing Contracts (listed by length of contract)
        • Pedro Adames (31 yr old - C) - expires after S62 - 1/$1.1M
          • .258, 5 HR
        • John Martin (30 yr old - RP) - expires after S62 - 1/$1.3M
          • 1.40 whip, 4.26 era
        • Miguel Castillo (37 yr old  RP) - expires after S62 - 1/$5.5M
          • S61: 1.31 whip, 3.69 era - SuB
        • Rick Crouse (32 yr old - 1B) - expires after S62 - 1/$5.6M
          • .280, 40 HR, 7 SB
        • Willis Everidge (38 yr old - SP) - expires after S63 - 2/$12M
          • S61 All-Star
          • 1.33 whip, 4.34 era
        • Arthur Clippard (37 yr old - RP) - expires after S63 - $12.5M
          • 1.33 whip, 4.06 era
        • Ed Blevins (28 yr old - CF) - expires after S63 - 2/$13M
          • S61 All-Star
          • .260, 15 HR, 50 SB
        • Dan Hernandez (32 yr old - RP) - expires after S63 - 2/$15M
          • 1.34 whip, 4.16 era
        • Warren Axelrod (31 yr old - 2B) - expires after S63 - 2/$26M
          • .267, 30 HR, 10 SB
        • Gregorio Cordero (33 yr old - C) - expires after S63 - 2/$28M
          • S61 Silver Slugger & All-Star
          • .300, 40 HR
        • Paolo Gomez (34 yr old - SP) - expires after S64 - 3/$18M
          • 96-95, 1.36 whip, 4.30 era
      • Upcoming Free Agents
        • Fausto Cruz (39 yr old - P)
        • Felipe Canseco (36 yr old - P)
        • Javy Rodrigo (40 yr old - RP)
        • Josh Henry (30 yr old - SP)
        • Rafael Marquez (38 yr old - RP)
      • Prospects
        • 3B Irvin Chacin (S59 #15 pick)
        • 3B King Milton (S60 #29 pick)
        • C Earl Bailey (S61 #31 pick)

  • Cincinnati (NL)
    • Another one year owner, but this one is leaving partially because he has some real life friends in another league that they have more history in and he needs to cut back on a league. So unfortunately this one is the team. Sad to see him go, especially after taking the worst team in the league in S60 to the best team in the NL S61 and to the World Series; partially due to some promotions of top prospects - including one player who was on the ballot for both NL Rookie and NL MVP! But a lot to do with their free agent additions creative solution to their pitching holes. Lots to like about this team and its future. The prospects were position player focused but the recent owner filled the pitching need using tandems; which as I mentioned being the top team in the NL; worked out great for them.  

    • We'll look further at their current roster in a bit but let's look at the competition. An interesting division, I believe most though Buffalo would be rebuilding but they turned out a 91-71 season. DC was just above .500 but should be more competitive next season, and Columbus is likely entering a rebuild mode. As we mentioned this is a fantastic team to hit the ground running with some decent young depth. 
    • Last season Records
      • ML: 108-54 (1st)
      • AAA: 48-96 (4th)
      • AA: 84-60 (2nd)
      • A+: 77-68 (2nd)
      • A-: 49-95 (4th)
      • R: 35-41 (4th)
    • As we've said, the roster is set up nicely to jump straight in and perhaps win a title your first year in the league. 
      • (ages are listed as of the upcoming season)
      • Guaranteed Salary 
        • Last season's payroll: $85.5M
        • S62: $54.6M
        • S63: $37.8M
        • S64: $23.2M
        • S65: $28.3M
      • Arbitration Class
        • Asdrubal Unamuno (28 yr old - 2B) - Arb1
          • .230, 0 HR, 20 SB
        • Cliff Nixon (29 yr old - 2B) - Arb1
          • .255, 5 HR, 25 SB
        • Felipe Julio (28 yr old - RF) - Arb1
          • .250, 22 HR, 0 SB
        • Julio Valdes (27 yr old - C) - Arb1
          • .245, 35 HR, 0 SB
        • Sven Peters (29 yr old - 2B) - Arb2
          • .260, 7 HR, 40 SB
        • Jose Pulido (30 yr old - SP) - Arb1
          • 1.55 whip, 4.65 era
        • Juancito Guerrero (29 yr old - SP) - Arb1
          • 1.40 whip, 5.20 era
        • Ramiel Duran (30 yr old - P) - Arb1
          • 1.25 whip, 3.15 era
      • Contract Renewals
        • Darrell Schneider (23 yr old - RF)
          • S61: .279, 44 HR, 33 SB
        • Jacob Helms (25 yr old - SS)
          • S61: .245, 7 HR, 5 SB
        • Reese Bruce (26 yr old - LF)
          • S61: .325, 16 HR, 8 SB
          • Huge injury changed his outlook - dropped 7 OAV, recovered 1 OAV
        • Nolan Speier (27 yr old - P)
          • S61: 40 games, 98 ip, 1.28 whip, 3.76 era
        • Yuniesky Estrella (23 yr old - 2B)
          • S61: .263, 29 HR, 27 SB
      • Existing Contracts (listed by length of contract)
        • John Costello (32 yr old - SS) - expires after S62 - 1/$3.1M 
          • .235, 0 HR, 40 SB
        • Kip Price (25 yr old - 2B) - expires after S62 - 1/$2.9M 
          • .255, 15 HR, 80 SB
        • Ossie Crow (35 yr old - RP) - expires after S62 - 1/$6.8
          • 40 starts, 1.25 whip, 3.61 era
        • Wilton Perry (38 yr old - RP) - expires after S62 - 1/$5.1 w/ mutual
          • 59 games, 43/49 sv, 1.13 whip, 3.13 era
        • Toby Service (30 yr old - SS) - expires after S63 - 2/$7.4M 
          • .210, 15 HR, 30 SB
        • Onelki Moya (32 yr old - P) - expires after S63 - 2/$13.6M
          • 1.40 whip, 3.95 era
        • Alvin Bell (28 yr old - P) - expires after S65 - 4/$19.2M
          • 1.35 whip, 4.40 era
        • Douglas McCovey (30 yr old - P) - expires after S65 - 4/$33.4 w/ mutual
          • 1.30 whip, 4.25 era
        • Juan Latos (33 yr old - P) - expires after S65 - 4/$32.5M 
          • 1.15 whip, 3.30 era
        • Pete Marte (28 yr old - P) - expires after S65 - 4/$12.8M w/ mutual
          • 1.45 whip, 4.75 era
      • Upcoming Free Agents
        • Avisail Gonzales (32 yr old - RF)
          • S61: .284, 16 hr, 6 sb
        • David Andrus (31 yr old - C)
          • S61: .255, 20 hr, 1 sb
          • Acquired in season
        • Gus Snow (35 yr old - P)
          • S61: 41 starts, 1.35 whip, 3.55 era (tandem)
        • Ross Romero (35 yr old - P)
          • S61: 41 starts, 1.08 whip, 2.52 era (tandem)
      • Prospects
        • Owner before current one wasn't involved in IFA
        • Draft
          • 2B Preston Brock (S60 - #2 pick)
          • 2B Torey Hechavarria (S60 - #33 pick)
          • SP Endy Gonzales (S61 - #1 pick)

Monday, December 2, 2024

S61 Franchise Wins

Jack Torrance - contributing reporter

Thought this was a fun article we brought back last season, so making another update to it. 9,882 games played, means 4,941 is .500 - our top 11 franchises are above .500. 

How does your franchise stack up, does it have a history of winning or constantly rebuilding? Sometimes it just takes the right dedicated owner to get things turned around. Number of World Series championships are in [ ], League Championships are in ( ), and Division Titles in { }. 

  1. Houston - 5731 [7] (12) {30} 
  2. Atlanta - 5591 [9] {17} (31} 
  3. Buffalo - 55413 [3] (6) {17} 
  4. Santa Fe - 5227 [2] (2) {25} 
  5. New Orleans - 5189 [4] (7) {22} 
  6. Oklahoma City - 5164 [4] (9) {25}
  7. Tucson - 5104 [1] (1) {14} (+1)
  8. Boston - 5089 [1] (1) {9} (-1)
  9. Jacksonville - 5021 [3] (3) {11} (+1)
  10. Chicago - 5019 [3] (5) {20} (-1)
  11. Hartford - 5018 [1] (3) {21}
  12. Columbus - 4935 [0] (0) {13}
  13. Minnesota - 4923 [0] (0) {17} 
  14. Colorado Springs - 4910 [2] (5) {17}
  15. Salem - 4896 [1] (2) {15}
  16. Vancouver - 4879 [1] (2) {10}
  17. Cincinnati - 4871 [4] (8) {15} (+3)
  18. New York - 4870 [0] (2) {12} (-1)
  19. Philadelphia - 4848 [1] (1) {20} (-1)
  20. Helena - 4846 [1] (2) {18} (-1)
  21. Scottsdale- 4825 [0] (2) {11}
  22. Washington DC - 4800 [2] (8) {16} (-1)
  23. Huntington - 4763 [0] (2) {8} (+4)
  24. Anaheim - 4760 [4] (4) {12} (-1)
  25. Montreal - 4754 [0] (1) {8} (+1)
  26. Fargo - 4753 [1] (4) {12} (-1)
  27. Mexico City - 4748 [4] (4) {12} (-3)
  28. Austin - 4699 [1] (2) {12}
  29. Charleston - 4677 [0] (0) {2} 
  30. Dover - 4650 [0] (0) {11} 
  31. Augusta - 4594 [0] (2) {9} 
  32. Tacoma - 4544 [0] (3) {12} 

Friday, September 20, 2024

S61 Park and Location updates

Jack Torrance - contributing reporter

Here are the pack effects with last year's playoff teams in bold. 

Pitcher Parks - below 0.970

  • Tacoma - 0.793
  • Oklahoma City - 0.843
  • Anaheim - 0.941
  • Augusta - 0.904
  • Atlanta - 0.950
  • Buffalo - 0.953
  • Charleston - 0.956
  • Mexico City - 0.956
  • Jacksonville - 0.957
Neutral Parks 
  • Columbus - 0.991
  • Chicago - 0.993
  • Colorado Springs - 1.000
  • New York - 1.004
  • Washington DC - 1.004
  • Houston - 1.006
  • Cincinnati - 1.010
    • New Owner, was Pittsburgh - 1.000
  • Philadelphia - 1.010
  • Minnesota - 1.022
Hitter Parks - above 1.030
  • Vancouver - 1.035
  • Helena - 1.041
  • Fargo - 1.041
  • Salem - 1.043
  • Dover - 1.054
  • New Orleans - 1.069
  • Austin - 1.072
  • Montreal - 1.074
  • Boston - 1.111
  • Scottsdale- 1.119
  • Huntington - 1.134
  • Hartford - 1.134
  • Tucson - 1.194
  • Santa Fe - 1.332
Updated map below as Pittsburgh moves 300 miles west to Cincinnati. Rumor has it they stopped by Columbus to prank the Corgis by letting a bunch of cats loose in their stadium. Bonus feature of the map, we are currently showing locations of the fan bases (EDITOR NOTE: Apologies, I see some errors but I already closed it all out and didn't want to reopen photoshop. The file errored out on me and I already had to redo some of it. Next update will be better.)



Monday, August 19, 2024

S60 Open Letter to Owner

Catherine Trammell - contributing reporter





Dear Mr. norsk, 

Lucky all you Son's of Bitc...Odin fans are WEIRD! This has been your 21st season with the franchise and are currently lined up for a top 5 pick. Fans were delighted to have you move the franchise here after S39 from San Juan and Nashville the season before that; though the franchise under your reign is just 1352-1726 entering this season. That said, the fans are getting excited about the current rebuild you are working on and hoping to claim the franchise's first division title since the one you won your second season in the league, S41. I see the promo material starting already....Ready, Steady, Division Champs after Twenty!

To give the fans a little something to look forward to, let's take a look at what you've built over the years and where you might need some more focused attention. Let's start off with the International market.  

International Market
  • Us fans would rather see hot dog prices go down than continued funding in the international market. You've quietly been spending $5-8M since S56 but we are afraid its not turning into future major league talent. Your last productive IFA was Akinori Yoshii (DH) and Luigi Gil (SS) back in S44. Majority since have seen 8-10 professional years, with many not cracking the main lineup. The $5-8M is no longer going to cut it in today's market but diving into the deep end or getting out of the pool all together might be the toughest and most important decision that the Austin brass need to decide on. 
We've had a top 16 protected pick all but 2 years, the fans are starting to think you love seeing Austin's name in print on the blog and using the blog's scouts for the prospects you sign! First a quick look at those picks over the years. 
  • S41 - #15 - JO Ontiveros (2B)
    • 14 Pro years, 9 in the Majors - all for Austin. Career .263 hitter with 20-25 HR and 10-15 SB. 
  • S42 - #32 - lost due to signing Alberto Crespo (3B) to a 3/$15.6M deal where he had a .270 batting average but never cracked 12 HR or 12 SB. 
  • S43 - #12 - Donovan Romano (SS) 
    • 12 Pro years, 8 in majors. Lasted just 2 years in Austin before being traded for Larry Schultz (CF) and one other piece. Schultz was a .247 hitter, with 10-20 HR and a wide range of 10-25 SB. 
  • S44 - #14 - Hal Lawton (SP) 
    • 16 Pro / 8 ML, all with Austin. 262 starts, 76-110 lifetime record with a 1.41 WHIP, 4.76 ERA. 
  • S45 - #10 - Lou Porzio (RF) 
    • 14 Pro / 7 ML, all with Austin. .276 hitter, 20-25 HR, 10-15 SB. 
  • S46 - #7 - Johnny Jay (SP) 
    • 12 Pro / 9 ML, all with Austin, though he signed a minor league deal for S60 with Philly - Low A. 77-83 lifetime record with a 1.44 WHIP, 4.57 ERA. 
  • S47 - #7 - Trever Kendrick (SP) 
    • 12 Pro / 0 ML, retired having never cracked the major league roster. 
  • S48 - #15 - Ernest Clements (LF) 
    • 12 Pro / 6 ML and counting - signed through S62. Hitting .247, with 15-20 HR and 20ish SB. 
  • S49 - #15 - Mark Webster (2B) 
    • 11 Pro / 7 ML and counting - signed through S63. 
  • S50 - #10 - Rene Rhodes (SP) 
    • 10 Pro / 7 ML. Waived after Arb2 and claimed by Colorado Springs. Currently with Montreal. 48-76 lifetime, with 13/20 saves, 1.49 WHIP, and 5.51 ERA.
  • S51 - #11 - JD Maness (RF) 
    • 9 Pro / 1 ML, though not with Austin.  Never added to 40-man and claimed in Rule 5 by Mexico City in S55. Hit .234 with 8 HR and 10 SB that season, but was demoted the following year. 
  • S52 - #9 - Boone Rudolph (2B) 
    • 8 Pro / 0 ML though still with Austin. Not likely to crack the majors.  
  • S53 - #12 - Fausto Silverio (P) 
    • 7 Pro / 1 ML. We traded him S54 for Chris Gore (CF) & Lawrence Hutch (RP). Neither has cracked the ML cllub yetSilverio is currently 6-11, 7/21 in saves with a 1.46 WHIP and 4.99 ERA for Salem after being traded again in S55, then again in S58 to where he is now.  
  • S54 - #7 - Isaac Monroe (CF) 
    • 6 Pro / 3 ML, enters Arb2 next season. Hitting .280, and averaging 30 HR with nearly 20 SB. The fans fully expect an extension to be signed next season to avoid him walking in Arb3, but that's on you. 
  • S55 - #11 - Kane Byrdak (CF) 
    • 5 Pro / 0 ML. Offers plus upside on the base paths, but might struggle getting on base. Fans are still excited to see him in the lineup one day. 
  • S56 - #6 - Viosergy Barrett (SS) 
    • 4 Pro / 0 ML. His glove is slightly below your typical ML shortstop, but like most Odins to crack the ML roster, he offers plus power and speed, though he often struggles against pitchers. His plus range might help make up a little for the limited glove; but even if he gets to the ball will he make the play or cause another error? Might be interesting to see him in CF one day but that requires Monroe to shift elsewhere. 
  • S57 - #3 - Sammy Bennett (LF) 
    • 3 Pro /  0 ML. The most progression he's made this year is hitting lefties, though he's just slightly below league average at it. But also his glove, with limit arm strength he'll belong in COF or 1B; though not sure he has starter ratings in those areas; his overall value has a lot to do with his healthy and durability it seems. 
  • S58 - #7 - Freddy Smith (SS) 
    • 2 Pro / 0 ML. Freddy 'Freakin' Smith is one name the fans are looking forward to, by the way his comp of Dee Valle is currently on the MVP watch list with the career year he's having, though only slightly better than the S58 year in which Smith was comped to him.  Looking back, maybe  slightly adjust that comp as Valle has become a near 20/20 guy on a .300 average in recent seasons. 
  • S59 - #4 - Albert Dykstra (SS) 
    • 1 Pro / 0 ML. The blog projected him as a league average defensive Shortstop, but that's good news - because he should stick at Short allow Smith to shift his poor range to 2B. Perhaps Mark Webster is dealt for younger talent or an arm which seems to be needed in Austin. At the plate he was projected as a .290ish hitter with 25 HR. Odinians were thrilled with this pick!!
  • S60 - #4 - JJ Durham (P) 
    • 0 Pro / 0 ML. The recent drafts of Austin are looking much better, but like the blog said he's going to have a fantastic first pitch and it just keeps improving; not even through the first full year and it's already rated as an 85. He's slowly become the blog's favorite relief prospect in the game. 
Trades
  • The fans have noticed the Austin brass often steer away from trades, having only made 8 of them since taking over the franchise, 6 of them being between seasons 46-50; and 4 of the 8 with Atlanta - only the S50 Mark Yang deal was likely beneficial to the team.

Still not easy to rebuild with those 10-15 picks, depending on the quality of the drafts. With limited trades and limited FA signings, you choose to stick with those guys you draft and keep them around - much like Colorado Springs. We appreciate your dedication to the fan favorites! Unlike some retired players, we've noticed a lot of the former Odin's end up staying in Austin and becoming a big part of the community. Once a weird Austinite, always a weird Austinite. 

-Go get 'em Son's of Odin! 

Thursday, August 15, 2024

S60 - History by the Numbers

Jack Torrance - contributing reporter

Let's take a look at the league by the numbers over the last 20 seasons. Underlined are highs from last season. 
  • Most Hitting Stats
    • Hits - 1780 - S59 Huntington
      • Fewest: 1228 - S48 Philadelphia
    • Doubles - 324 - S51 New Orleans
      • Fewest: 130 - S57 New York
    • Triples - 47 - S55 OKC
      • Fewest: 7 - S54 Mexico City / S57 New York
    • Home Runs - 326 - S40 Santa Fe
      • Fewest: 88 - S57 Augusta
    • Runs - 1037 - S55  Atlanta
      • Fewest: 505 - S47 Washington DC
    • RBI - 1023 - S55  Atlanta
      • Fewest: 486 - S45 Florida (New Orleans)
    • BB - 700 - S42 Atlanta
      • Fewest: 363 - S51 Washington DC
    • K (least) - 771 - S59 Huntington
    • K (most) - 1356 - S48 Philadelphia
    • HBP - 109 - S49 Atlanta
      • Fewest: 27 - S52 Tucson (Scottsdale)
    • SB - 444 - S55 OKC
      • Fewest: 10 - S56 Chicago
    • CS (least) - 7 - S46 Iowa City (Augusta)
    • CS (most) - 116 - S57 OKC
    • SB% -  86.7% - S45 Buffalo (98 SB / 15 CS)
      • Lowest: 33.7% - S55 Huntington (29 SB / 57 CS)
    • AVG - .303 - S59 Huntington
      • Lowest: .223 - S48 Philadelphia
    • OBP - .380 - S59 Huntington
      • Lowest: .279 - S48 Philadelphia
    •  SLG - .502 - S58 Huntington
      • Lowest: .323 - S57 Augusta
    • OPS - .873 - S59 Huntington
      • Lowest: .618 - S59 New York
    • 20 Season Average: 760 R, 201 HR, 738 RBI, 509 BB, 1080 K, 126 SB, 57 CS, .261 AVG, .327 OBP, .415 SLG, .743 OPS
  • Most Pitching Stats
    • Complete Games - 33 - S46 Tampa Bay (Mexico City)
      • Fewest: 69 times teams have finished with 0 Complete Games
    • Shutouts - 11 - S42 Tampa Bay (Mexico City)
      • Fewest: 250 times teams have finished with 0 Shutouts
    • Wins - 124 - S55 Atlanta
      • Fewest: 41 - S58 New York
    • Saves - 71 - S47 Colorado Springs
      • Fewest: 20 - S55 Dover
    • Blown Saves - 5 - S49 New York (60/65), S55 Atlanta (59/64), S57 New York (25/30)
      • Most: 28 - S40 Monterrey (Charleston - 49/77), S43 Houston (44/72), S56 Santa Fe (50/78)
    • Save Percentage - .923 - S49 New York (60/65)
      • Lowest: .512 - S56 Dover (21/41)
    • Innings Pitched - 1497 1/3 - S44 Trenton (Hartford)
    • Hits - 1098 - S42 OKC
      • Highest: 1786 - S50 Huntington
    • Runs - 401 - S43 OKC
      • Highest: 1136 - S44 Dover
    • Home Runs - 111 - S42 OKC
      • Highest: 299 - S58 New York
    • Walks - 380 - S50 Colorado Springs
      • Highest - 700 - S57 Washington DC
    • Strikeouts - 1306 - S43 Honolulu (Scottsdale)
      • Fewest: 868 - S58 Colorado Springs
    • K/9 - 8.02 - S43 Honolulu (Scottsdale)
      • Lowest: .697 - S57 Colorado Springs
    • OAV - .207 - S42 OKC, S46 OKC
      • Highest: .300 - S59 Dover
    • WHIP - 1.04 - S43 OKC, S46 OKC
      • Highest: 1.66 - S43 Santa Fe
    • ERA - 2.30 - S43 OKC
      • Highest: 6.54 - S44 Dover
    • 20 Season Average: 1452 IP, 509 BB, 1081 K, .261 OAV, 1.38 WHIP, 4.33 ERA, 44/60 saves (.730%), 6.695 K/9
  • Fielding Stats
    • Assists - 1862 - S41 Jackson (Jacksonville)
      • Fewest: 1352 - S56 Dover
    • Errors - 59 - S56 Hartford
      • Most: 164 - S55 Washington DC
    • Double Plays: 506 - S40 Charlotte (Huntington)
      • Fewest: 268 - S56 Tacoma
    • 20 Season Average: 1624 assists, 102 errors, 386 double plays
  • Number of 110 W seasons - 24
    • Atlanta owns 7 of those. 
  • Number of 115 W seasons - 9
    • Atlanta owns 4 of those. 
    • Most recent was Huntington S58
  • Number of 110 L seasons - 15
    • Former NY owner owned 4 of those, all over the last 4 seasons. 


Sunday, August 4, 2024

S60 Round Table - rules

Our Editor-In-Chief thought a sit down with the commissioner was long overdue. We even brought him Timmy Horton donuts as a peace offering! So far he’s done a fantastic job of pushing the little red button and keeping fights between him and the blog rather than between owners. As we’ve written about in the past, that’s partially because of the great owners we have here in Cobbfather. Owners who respect the integrity of the game. Owners who want to challenge each other and try to keep Cobbfather as one of the best worlds within WIS. But that is also why we find ourselves here today, to discuss the elephant in the room. The recent overt tanking that has been going on is excessive.

We’d like to welcome you to debate (as an adult) any of these items on global chat within the league, or feel free to jump on discord where we find it easier to have a back and forth. World chat is really meant for one liners, not full conversations. Or, if you'd prefer to have a quite voice; feel free to site mail Commish Daubs. 

Editor: Welcome Commissioner Daubs, can you remind us; what season did you take over as commish of Cobbfather? But before we jump into the discussion, let our readers know what have you enjoy most out of this role and what do you hope is your legacy as Commissioner of the league? 

Commish: Honestly, I do not remember what season I took over. It was likely around Season 47 or 48 -- I just know that it's been over 3 years. 

What I've enjoyed most of out of the role is getting to know some of the people on the other side of the keyboard. We all come from various places and points in our life and I enjoy learning about people -- whether from our New Owner Interviews, or interactions. I don't really care much about a legacy. What I care about is leaving Cobbfather a better world than when I took over, if that makes sense. Many seasons ago, there was a big blowout between our Commissioner and others in the world. FW did an amazing job stepping in and righting that ship and if I can be considered half as good as he was, I'm fine with that. 

Editor: Alright, now for the elephant in the room, the recent tanking. It’s gotten rather bad, the last couple of seasons. To the point we had one team vying for their 5th straight #1 overall draft pick. From the discussions I've heard, no other world within WIS has had a team with more than 3 straight #1s. Some owners have chosen to play a AAA roster at the ML level in an effort to save money for IFA spending and to improve their chances at the #1 pick. Now we understand every owner can build the team the way they want, but that’s an excessive route to build a “super team”. Nobody tell Kevin Durant, he might try to join. What in your mind can be done to bring back some the competitive balance to the world? We’ve heard a few suggest a minimum win rule, spending limits, or even transfer limits; what’s your hot take? 

Commish: I've played in worlds with a variety of different rules. Personally, I do not like a minimum salary floor because it does take away from owners (who are FAR better than me at this game) to be creative with their squads. I'm not opposed to it if that is what we want to do though. 

We've already addressed playing people out of position, but it's difficult to police on day-to-day basis. If I had the power to strip draft picks, I would. Let me rephrase. MLB has now set it up that if you have a top 5 pick in Season A, in Season B your next highest pick is 9 or 10 (or something like that). I would love that power, but it would probably go to my head. 

I think the simplest solution is to have a rolling Minimum Win Requirement. Something along the lines of 55/115/180 over a 3 year period. A new owner would automatically get 1 season "free" so to speak. We know this solution wouldn't end all tanking, but it would alleviate owners playing guys who shouldn't be above AA ball in the majors just to accumulate more losses. 

Editor: I understand the 3 year rolling window, but how strict is that? 50 games is acceptable but 49 gets you a ban? That's just the sim not liking someone for an extra game or two. What about 48? Is there really a difference between a 48 win team and a 50 win one? How far does it go, 47? At some point yes there's a clear difference. Everyone understands you have to draw the line somewhere, but I wouldn't use a screwdriver for a nail. It will get the job done, but there's a much better tool for that. Maybe a MWR is fixing the wrong problem in tanking. That said, I completely understand that it's the easiest to police. 

Commish: I think the rules will mostly be a guideline and not 100% black and white. I'm all for giving new owners a year grace period. If we set a MWR at 55 wins and an owner (new or well established) ends at 54 but are doing the correct things (minors stocked, competent ML team, etc). I'd rather put that owner on probation and give them another season. That's why I generally prefer a rolling progressive MWR, but it's not a deal breaker for me by any means. 

Editor: Playing devil's advocate, given those antics of a select few owners, don't you think a MWR just delays when the tanking is done and pushes it to the end of the season; when arguably has a greater effect on the playoff race compared to over the course of an entire season? I imagine some of those teams will reach the minimum on the year (or year 3) and then do everything in their power to not win another game; which is fantastic if you are in a wildcard hunt and get to play 1 or 2 of them the last month of the season. 

Commish: This is the problem with the mentality of some Americans. They want to find out the worst in a situation. From my recollection, games at the beginning of the season count just as much as games at the end of the seasons. So, when you win doesn't really matter. Plus, and I could be wrong, but in other worlds that I participate in that have a MWR, I've never seen a team that gets to say 55-60 decide they'll lose the rest of of their games and end up with only 65 wins. 

Editor: Fair, the only world I know is Cobbfather; I just know people on the internet and they always look for the loophole, look at NY who tried to circumvent Arb by demoting the AL Cy Young to AAA to try and get another year out of him. Luckily WIS patched that loophole so it didn't work and he just ended up wasting a year in the minors, though that player did win the AAA Cy Young that season. Ha! The players out of position has been discussed, but do you think there should be a hard rule about it? The real issue is the type of players on some of these teams and not just their W/L record. Pause on how it would take to accomplish this...for now....could you imagine a minimum rating in certain categories for common players? Role players and possibly even platoon types could be given exceptions. For example, a pitcher's whose control is below 50 is the owner just asking for a Loss. By the way, there are 6 Starters and 9 Relievers who are below 50 in control! I didn't look but I imagine their average WHIP is something like 1.65 at best. Even 85+ splits or 100 P1/P2 are not going to make up for that. Though that is the clear problem; no one category is the driver for how well a player does. For a hitter, 90+ power could make up for lower contact or splits. And then how do you define different player types like a Shortstop compared to a First Baseman; of course the SS is going to be the worse hitter; his value has a lot to do with his fielding. But I think we can all agree, there are clearly certain players who do not belong on a major league roster. One more flaw in that system is older players on current contracts; do they get a pass if they drop below the mark? Good idea in theory, but still leaves a lot of question marks. 

Commish: I'm fine with the minimum rating, but how will that exactly be monitored? Everyone has different budgets and sees players differently (which is a good and bad flaw in this game). So, someone with a low budget might see a player as an overall of 60 (or control of 60), while someone with a much higher budget will see that player in the 40s. Is there a way to balance it? Possibly. And that would be something I'd be willing to discuss. 

I would think veterans on an existing contract that start taking a ratings dive would be "immune" to what we're talking about. It's the 40-year-olds that gets a 2-year contract where his skills have diminished so much that he should be on the golf course and not trying to play in CF. 

Editor: Everyone sees the same current ratings, which is what we were referring to; not projected ratings. So it wouldn't be hard to figure out whose low and crosses that mark. Not nominating myself, but the blog keeps up with some of that pretty easily and also has seasons worth of data to reference to see how the average major leaguer rates over the last 8 seasons. Perhaps I'll get one of the writers to pull something together on what the average rating is at each position for anyone who accumulates at least 300 at bats. Why 300 you ask? Sparta!  

Commish: I'd be fine with a minimum rating if we can come to a consensus that makes sense. Overall is most logical, but then you would have catchers that are low, but might be a 99 pitch calling, as well as defensive shortstops. 

Editor: Overall would be the easiest, but the also the worst because it's heavy dependent on some categories that don't directly effect the production on the field. I remember having a high OAV SP back in the day and it was purely driven by a high stamina and durability. Just because he could long innings and often, doesn't mean he was valuable. The ratings could only apply for starters as we said; allowing role players, platoons, back-ups to have some flexibility in their ratings. With the thought being, the main team - with no injuries - is ML ready. Everybody seems to like the no players being played out of position; but that's too general of a rule - it needs some definition to it otherwise it's just an opinion. The Catcher at Centerfield that always comes up, per WIS the average CF has defensive ratings of 85, 85, 60, 65. You could easily say a player needs to be within 15-20 points (still makes them awful at that position) at each rating; so the worst player at CF would be 65, 65, 40, 45 - at least that keeps C, 1B, and DHs from playing there. But could we do better? Yes probably so, but is 10 points difference too strict? 75, 75, 50, 55? If you do a player search for CFs right now, the worst in each defensive category is 73, 63, 46, 48. That doesn't take into account anyone playing out of position. 

To get even crazier and tougher to track - we could say at least two ratings need to match or exceed the big league average with the other two being no more than 10-15 points; that at least means the worst CF might be a 70, 70, 60, 65 --- 85, 85, 45, 50 --- or some combination there of. 

With regards to hitters, for hitters to exceed 250 ABs since S54, there have been 21 players whose contact, power, and both splits have fallen below 50. 5 of them have been part of New York Empire's recent tanking scheme; but all of them are Shortstops; though a few do fall below league average for that position. To take a different look, checking out players who have a sub .240 wOBA - meaning their averages are usually below .250, strikeouts above 100, and walks below 40. Fangraphs says anything below .290 is awful as a reference point. Taking out SSs for ease of discussion, a common thread is sub 50 vR and often sub 50 vL. Power varies as some have more speed and contact is all over the place since that appears to be more about consistency from season to season; you end up with a list of 10 or so players that likely didn't below in a starting rotation. Maybe let's just discuss the fielding side and leave the hitting and pitching for another blog post after some research has been done. 

Commish: I think our league is now to the point where we can call a fellow owner out on playing someone out of position and deal with it that way. I say that for this reason -- draft picks, as well as international free agents, will show a player as SS or 2B and when you see their ratings, there is no chance that's what they should be. But, if the owner just keeps it at WIS "default" then are they really playing someone out of position? In the future, we can look at the pitchers and hitter ratings, but I can see that going very extreme and turning a lot of owners off. If there is a MWR put in place, I think some of those issues of hitters and pitchers (being on a ML roster) will be much more infrequent. 

Editor: Who cares what the projections say at IFA signing or Rule 4 draft; we are talking about once a player makes the Major League --- there all current ratings are the same so it's clear when someone is "out of position". With that said, next topic. What’s your take on the international market? Is it working in a way that you find positive for the world? WYW was nearly $50M, that's more than double the amount someone can budget for in prospects. Most of the time the high IFAs will sign for the $20-30M range; that was just an odd year and a great player. But if their team isn't bottoming out without a truly competitive team at the ML level should they be able to transfer all that money? In the blog's opinion, no; but it's a hard line in the sand to draw. Owners as long as they are taking care of business with their ML club; let money be spent how they want. After all, if someone decides to play the FA game; there's no limitation on how much they don't spend on prospects. 

Thinking outside the box, would there be a way to tie in how much a team could transfer based upon the number of wins from the previous year? Example: if they win 55 games, they can only transfer 80% of their unspent Player budget. If they win 65 games, they can transfer 90%, or 75 games and 100%. Obviously just making up numbers for discussion purposes. The actual Wins and Percent could be debated amongst the owners on discord. But sounds like the Commissioner's office might need to hire an accountant. 

Commish: I think it's difficult to limit spending in the international market. I mean, we can always cap a player at $20M, but I honestly don't like it. It's the same way I'd be opposed to not allowing only transferring a certain % of money. If we could figure out how to get better draft prospects in here, it might make spending on international less, but that's not something any of us can do. 

Editor: How about the minors? There are plenty of teams at all levels that have completely exhausted pitchers and tired position players by the 25th game of the season. AI could run the minors but people don't like letting it have that control; but wouldn't it be nice if up and down the rosters teams were run smoothly? It doesn't even take much effort to make sure your minors are balanced if you don't trust AI to do it. 

Commish: I know that running the minors is on the back burner for a few of our owners--not only here, but in other worlds. We can always put some rule in place for people to maintain their minors, but is there a way to penalize someone for not? I'm open to ideas on that one. I get why people don't want AI to run the minors (promotions, inactives, etc.), but it's a simple solution in case someone is too busy to manage. 

Editor: Since it really doesn't take much to maintain a minor league, perhaps we could do a three strike system for people neglecting them? After the third strike, they are disciplined in some way. Okay, so there are a few options for rules. But who carries out these rules? Who has ultimate veto power? Are the rules clearly black and white? If you fall below whatever is agreed are is that owner immediately banned from the league or is there a probation period where they get to stay in the league another season but are limited to $0 transfers or maybe even losing the ability to sign their draft pick? Is that up to you as commissioner or would you foresee forming a small committee to review any discrepancies? Sometimes you need quick decisions made and not to let them linger into the next off-season, but a committee gives a voice and let's a discuss happen because not everything is black and white in this world. Is it a rotating committee, is it just the most senior people, or maybe just the blog editor gets to decide the fate and makes a rule that Cobbfather will no longer allow franchises to be located in Canada. After all, it's for the good of the game.

Commish: First, the blog writer will have no authority whatsoever. He can be a cold, callous human being and sometimes that can just rub others the wrong way. 

As discussed, previously, I'm not a big fan of limiting transfer money and such. Limiting draft picks (proposed by slash) is an idea and curious how that would work? But, if someone has that "sentence", what stops them from drafting the top player rand signing them before some of us even get up in the morning of the draft results? Would that owner automatically be booted? 

We can form a committee if that is something the league wants. Generally, I counsel almost everyone. When making decisions that affect the league. I typically look towards those owners that have been here the longest. If that's general ideas, I'll get feedback from a variety of owners, including those I recruited into Cobbfather. 

Editor: Awwww, you have me down perfectly. Thank you. How do you plan to go about owners being able to weigh in? Would a vote make the most sense? Considering it’s difficult for owners to vote on Awards and the Hall; what are your thoughts on using a percent of those who vote? If an owner decides to not vote, if they abstain - meaning they don’t care which way the results go; they will continue in this world no matter what; going with a majority makes some sense rather than needing X amount of votes. 

Commish: Great question. I'm all for voting because this is a demoracy and not a dictatorship that some people believe it is. I don't know if a simple majority or 2/3 vote makes the most sense? My opinion is if an owner abstains from voting, then that is a yes for this purpose. As you said, if they don't care, then to me that means they would be for the change. I'm sure some owners will be adamant against and will take that into consideration. 

Editor: Now we have to ask the follow-up question. What happens if an owner doesn’t agree with adding any new rules. Do you expect to have to replace any owners once these rules are put into place? After all, it's a very sensitive subject with rules on how to run a team or how successful an owner needs to be to stay within in the league; especially in the days of leagues having to merge together because there are not enough new owners coming into the game. Too bad there isn't a chance for a relegation system to be put into place. 

Commish: I don't expect all owners to agree with adding any rules. Will owners have to be replaced? Possibly. I've communicated with enough owners where they understand where I'm coming from. The goal is not to be restrictive--the goal is to set some rules in place to allow the world to thrive for many, many, many more seasons. My hope is that we have 0 turnover and all owners decide they want to try and give at least one season to whatever new rules are decided upon. The nice thing is there are other owners that have expressed interest from my other dealings and worlds that would be willing to step in. 

Editor: How long do you foresee yourself being the commish of the world? Do you have someone in mind who could fill your shoes and keep the balance to the world? Hopefully you do better than Obe Won, Anakin didn't quite bring balance to the force.....or did he? Darth Daubs has an interesting ring to it.  

Commish: First, Darth Daubs has an AMAZING ring to it! But I've said this before, and I do mean it--this world is one of the easiest to be Commissioner for. Generally, there isn't much to deal with, and then there will be an occasional season where shit hits the fan and I feel like I've gotten gray hair (not that you can see it on my head). No one should ever want me to be a mentor for being a commissioner, but if we get a couple of rule sin place, I'll be commissioner as long as people still want me to be. But, if someone expresses interest in being commissioner, I have no problem turning over the title to another owner. 

Editor: Well thank you for taking the time to sit with us. It was a pleasure stuffing our face with Tim Horton's, but it's time for some real food and back to America! A few rule options that have been discussed, obviously not all are supported by the Commish or the Editor just getting them on the table:

  • Minimum Win Rule/Requirement
    • 1 year vs 3 year rolling
  • Players out of position
    • General rule vs hard lined requirements
    • Minimum Player Ratings
      • Fielding only  vs look into Hitter and Pitcher requirements
  • IFA Caps
    • Transfer limits
    • Cap per player
  • Minor league activity
    • Must keep up vs whatever happens happens
  • Voting Rules into place
    • Simple majority vs % of league
      • Abstaining is a vote for agreeing to the rule change.
  • Final decision
    • Commissioner vs Committee
  • Official name of Daubs
    • Commissioner Daubs vs Darth Daubs
  • Punishments / Probation
    • To be determined by who makes the final decision?

Wednesday, July 31, 2024

S60 Needs

 Jack Torrance - contributing reporter

Now that we've passed the halfway point of the season, and the deadline is just days away let's take a look at what the blog-o-sphere thinks the needs of each franchise are. We'll see who makes what moves by the deadline. 
  • Anaheim - Relief Pitching. They lead the league in percentage of inherited runners scored, allowing 41% to cross the plate where league average is just 29%. A late inning defensive replacement could actually improve the existing bullpen as well. They are also #2 in blown saves. An updated bullpen would go a long way for this season's team. 
  • Atlanta - Starting Pitching. This likely has more to do with their starters slow start than it does their talent. After the first 40 games their pitching had a 50 grade rating on a 20-80 scale. After the most recent update, they  are up a 70! They've allowed a few more fly balls this season than league average.  
  • Augusta - IFA. The team falls near the bottom in most stats but not really at the bottom in many; so props to them for not bottoming out. But what they need is New York and Chicago to spend their IFA budgets elsewhere or to find an IFA that those two franchises do not. You've got to ask yourself one question: Do you feel lucky? Well, do ya, punk?
  • Austin - Defense. The team ranks near the bottom in the league in DER (Defense Efficiency Ratio), meaning they are not making the most use out of balls put in play. Pair that with leaguing the league in Unearned Runs and you can see how even the slightest defensive upgrades would improve this team. 
  • Boston - Run on the same cylinder. The team is actually doing well and slightly above average in most every category. Is it a clubhouse issue and the team just isn't jellying together?  The slightest adjustments might see them turn the corner. I'd expect a late season run for these guys. 
  • Buffalo - Cher to turn back time. Buffalo is on pace for their worst franchise season ever; which is surprising given bjc30's successful track record season after season; he even took the division last year but unless they can turn things around, they are looking at a potential lottery draft pick. Buffalo fans have to hope for a pick within the top 10 but it might be in the 10-12 range. 
  • Charleston - Glasses. The club leads the majors in worst K/BB, so anything to help the team see better at the plate would be a big improvement. They also need some more power in their lineup. So either PEDs, corked bats, or a new weight room at their facility would be an upgrade!
  • Chicago - A Major League lineup. Cutting ties with 75% of the ML roster and signing players still on the FA market would go a long way to improve this team from the "talent" that it is. I can think of one other need, but let's go with the first. It's debatable, but their 25 rating on a 20-80 scale finds them in last place for their lineup. They also aren't playing much defense, it may not be accounted for in errors but their DER is league worst. 
  • Colorado Springs - Less focus on fielding. The team is 4th in DER but we all know when Colorado Springs rebuilds they go glove first; so the plan is working. There seems to be a disagreement between team owner and AI's rankings but they are near the bottom in run differential and and are near the top of the league in singles. Base hits are great, but you need 4 of them in an inning to score a single run. Beat you didn't do that math in your head! If they could pick up a few bats their record would show it. 
  • Columbus - Time. Columbus picked up some help in their mid-season trades with Charleston and Scottsdale; they are now considered one of the two favored teams to win the National League with Tacoma. Their pitching received the top rating and while their bats were just a 65; I'd expect with Smalling and Garces now on the roster that will improve. Just give it time. 
  • Dover - Draft Redo. This team already has the easiest division in the majors; the winner of it will most likely have a losing record. But given SS Reynolds outlook, the club could likely go for a redo of this season's draft.  If they want to win the division, improving their defense and picking up a starter who can log some quality starts would be key. Both would go a long way; though neither likely gets them above .500 for the season. 
  • Fargo - A Prospect. After their Rule 4 draft pick not signing, and zero IFA signings, this rebuilding franchise just needs a single prospect to call this season a win. They did however unload Fred Carter for depth; just not sure they picked up a solid future Major Leaguer. 
  • Hartford - Quality Starts. The team ranks down there with Charleston, Pittsburgh, and Vancouver for lowest quality starts in the league. Their defense has been slightly better than league average but have also limited unearned runs. Their bats have the power but they could use a little more contact and runners on base. 
  • Helena - Pitching. The hitting on this team has been top of the league, but they rank well below average for quality starts,  but just leave average in OAV and strike outs, though they are also slightly below average on walks and even lower on HRs. The IR% is league average; not that there's anything being average; right Vancouver? But in this case, this is supposed to be a top 5 team; with some pitching upgrades would go a long way. 
  • Houston - The AL to chill the F out. Any other run Houston would be sitting pretty and while the are a great team they haven't distanced themselves from the other top AL teams....yet. The team is doing all the right things and should end up paying for the Al title. If you wanted to point out one thing it's the base running, 74 SBs but a league leading 46 CSs. 
  • Huntington - Pitching. Though much like Houston and Atlanta this is likely more of a slow start than anything. Huntington has the pitching, they just need to turn it on for the second half. The QS% is league average, their IRS% is slightly high but they just added some bullpen help, their DER is a bit low but not by much. Their K/BB is lowest in the league by a good margin so they are not giving up many free outs. 
  • Mexico City - Move to NL. This team in the NL is competing for the League Title, in the AL it feels like they fall into Tier 2 but luckily the playoffs are anyone's game so they have shot at least; just might be an uphill battle. But if there's one city that can do it, it's Mexico City. Un cerveza por favor!
  • Minnesota - Extra Base Hits. Slightly below average in hits but towards the top in singles. Let's push the limits a bit. Pitching could use some improvements but all the single ladies in Minny can't score by themselves. 
  • Montreal - Stop Being Average. They are gearing up for a Wildcard 2 slot, but the team's power rankings and stats to date say they are almost exactly league average. Don't get us wrong, that's not a bad thing; but are they gunning for a title or are they rebuilding? Hard to do both.  
  • New Orleans - Reality. The team entered a rebuild but you wouldn't know that by the standings. They are currently fighting the Eastern Canadians for Wildcard 2 but the team is over performing. What they really need is a dose of a reality check to bring them back down and improve their draft stock next season. Oh and to stop running so much; 46 SB, 34 CS. OUCH!
  • New York - Help. The team was looking quite awful to start the season but a hot streak has helped. To be honest what this team needs now is to shift out of their rebuild instead of stockpiling prospects at AAA and get back to a respectable franchise.  
  • Oklahoma City - Hits with runner's in scoring position. Pitcher's are rarely an issue with the pitcher's park in OKC, but the bats just haven't come around this year. The team is league average in batting average and runs scored; but lacks some power. They lead the league in stolen bases, per usual, but if you can't knock those guys in; what does it matter that they stole a base? 
  • Philadelphia - A break. Just like the needs article back in S54, the team needs a break. They keep trying to climb out of the bottom of the league and miss the bottom 10 this year but they are only in the division race because nobody seems to want to win the division; all teams are under .500. The team had a great run, but maybe this is the year they deal Al Cervantes for some additional prospects. 
  • Pittsburgh - Major League players. The team hah fallen slightly below the New Yorks and Chicagos of the world but without the cool factor of being New York or Chicago - but at least their murder rate in the city is less? All three teams have very similar production; perhaps its just a strength of schedule issue difference between the three? Either way, some new ML players would turn this team around; though the current free agents have been sitting around long enough that I doubt they add much this season. 
  • Salem - Pitching. Salem has the highest ERA and IRS% of the top 10 teams. If they are going to survive in the playoffs they'll need to fixture those issues. Pitching can be a difference maker come playoff time. Appears it might be a control issue, as they are granting too many free bases with too few strikeouts.  
  • Santa Fe - Playoffs to start. The team is doing all the right things and while we could say they need to improve pitching, that's easier said than done in such a hitter friendly park. The team is playing great defense which will help that pitching and their bats are playing as expected. Curious to see how the teams performs comes playoff time. 
  • Scottsdale - The next offseason to get here. This past off-season the new owner was able to shed some contracts and recently traded away their higher long term contracts so they are making progress for that rebuild. But they also have decisions to make on Spud Campbell and Jackson Benson; do they try and move their young talent for prospects while their contract values are right and still offer years of control? I'm sure they'd listen to any deal another franchise would be willing to make. But since those trades the team has nose dived, the owner better make adjustments before they become a top feeding team. Getting Lowry back from injury will help the bats and Foster back to help the rotation. Don't get us wrong, still a long way from having a winning record but we don't think they bottom out. 
  • Tacoma - Power. A power bat for a 1-2 punch with reigning NL MVP 1B Page. Their power ranking dropped drastically due to the hitting or lack there of. Now yes, they play in a huge pitcher's park; but you still need to score runs. They had a chance to acquire some bats in the offseason but holding steady. We'll see if it pays off this year. Either way, I'd look for them to make some tweaks next season if this one doesn't work out for them. Their future is bright even if they are below average in hitting across the board. 
  • Tucson - Pitching. Saying pitching this season seems repetitive but Tucson is well below average on the pitching side of the game, in fact the 4th worst ERA and 3rd most HR, 4th most BB, and bottom 10 K. Seems a deal between them and Tacoma could balance out both teams. Perhaps Laxton in a deal? Not sure it makes Tucson a playoff team this year, but it might be geared more for next season. 
  • Vancouver - Same thing as S54 Needs - move out of Canada. Oh and walk more / strike out less. The team is bottom 5 in the league in K/BB and in Free Outs, where they average 8 CS+K a game which means they basically limit themselves to 6 innings a game. Git Gud Canada! By the way, same report as S54...guess Canada really is behind the times and slow to catch up to America the beautiful! 
  • Washington DC - One More Year. The club is looking at being above .500 for the first time since S53 and only the second time since S39!!! Keltic needs to stick with his game plan on the rebuild even if the division is getting weaker. Give it at least another year before you go full steam ahead! 

Friday, July 19, 2024

S60 The Worst List

 Jack Torrance - contributing reporter


With the first power rankings of the year up, let's shift gears to the bottom of those rankings. In the current 'era' of rebuilding in Cobbfather, let's take a look at players that may not be up to snub. We compiled a list of players who don't have a single value (contact, power, vL, vR, eye) above a 80 rating. Over the years the average ML starter has at least a 70 across the board, so we'll take that into account. And given the specialty of bench/role players to possibly be defense first (or only) we've elected to only look at players who have a starting gig, and if it's a platoon we've only taken into account the side of the plate they are platoon on. Another words if they platoon vL and their vR is a 12; we've ignored them on this list. We have also only taken into account the vL & vR w/ DH for AL teams and vL & vR w/out DH for NL teams. 

We've created our own formula to rank each player which also includes their defensive ranking so this isn't just a look at their hitting ratings; though that was the initial starting process. At some point we hope to get The Best article posted as well, just depends on how long it really takes to get this one researched. 

Editor note: It took a while to write this so in the every changing scenery of the ML rosters; adjustments could have already been made to remove these lesser players. 

  • Catcher
    • This one is tricky given how much effect a catcher's pitch calling could have on a rotation; depending on which camp you belong to in that debate. Some say a 10 point difference in PC is worth very little in terms of cERA but others will say it's worth at least 0.20 in cERA adjustments. Others will say a veteran pitching staff doesn't need the PC as they'll call their own pitches. 
    • Cleuluis Lowry (Hartford) - Just shows that even a championship caliber team can have a lowly starter. Pitch calling of 88 should help out those pitchers even though the need for a high pitch calling is highly debated by other experts in other leagues. I will add this one might not be fair because it appears Hartford might be making catching adjustments at the time of this writing. 
      • Ratings: 36, 39, 50/44, 11
  • First Base
    • Dennis Tamura (New York) - He'll win the AL Gold Glove without a doubt but given his Rookie level production at the plate, we have to include him here. He'd be close to winning a Gold Glove at Shortstop as well if it weren't for the slightly underrated glove. Surprisingly he's actually hitting .243 avg/.506 ops with 3 more k then hits and 19 more k then bb. Tamura is actually the worst rated bat in all of Cobbfather at the ML level...and he's a starter!
      • Ratings: 39, 5, 20/33, 19
  • Second Base
    • Vic Arguelles (New York) - This 35 rated power hitter is actually batting in the cleanup spot for New York. He also falls below league average defensively at every category. He sports a career 18 HRs and a .238 avg/.632 ops over 1054 at-bats. We'll see what the worst shortstop looks like, but this might be the worst overall starter in Cobbfather. How is he even above AA?
      • Ratings: 63, 35, 54/33, 57
  • Third Base
    • Dellin Garces (Pittsburg) - The only thing holding Garces back from a potential gold glove is his accuracy rating but give the contact and power; he had to make this list. Last year he ended the season with 3 hr and a .237 avg/.579 ops; striking out 6 more times than he had hits. 
      • Ratings: 43, 14, 48/53, 46
  • Shortstop
    • Another tough one to gauge given the importance of a solid shortstop, many owners decide to take the hit at the plate to help prevent runs in the field. Close calls were Lewis Gaetti (Chicago) & Rob Webster (Philadelphia) but both are above average in the field. Though Gaetti's bat basically belongs in A- and Webster in AA. But where's the line at Short? When you start looking at defensive liabilities at short, their bats get closer to the 60/65 range. Babe Benincasa (Columbus) comes to mind as his arm strength and accuracy are more than 5 points below average but his bat is supposed to be nearly twice as good as the other two mentioned. Platoons are generally more often used here. With so many ifs, we'll leave The Worst Shortstop off the list...for now. 
  • Left Field
    • Timo Hara (New York) - Now if this was the worst starter on this franchise nobody would bat an eye, though seeing his ratings shows just how easy it is to find major league average hitters for Left Field. I'd imagine the majority of owners might not like Hara as an option but would find it acceptable for a rebuilding franchise to have a AAA/AAAA player in their lineup. 
      • Ratings: 64, 62, 61/55, 69
  • Center Field
    • Some say this is another tough spot as we've seen all ranges of fielders playing CF in Cobbfather, from DH types to Catchers to alternate Shortstops. Do they receive a lot of action in the field? No, but enough to still cause a difference to potential runs given up. 
    • Manuel Cueto (Chicago) - Is this the worst catcher we've seen in Chicago, by no means but at least those guys had bats. Cueto's career .234 avg/ .576 ops goes a lot way to help the rebuilding team gain an earlier pick in the follow year's draft. 
      • Ratings: 30, 17, 54/50, 53
  • Right Field
    • What should be the 4th easiest spot to fill even with a bat first type player. 
    • Ober Martin (New York) - Similar to Left Field these are awful numbers and likely to be a AAA/AAAA depending on their defensive ratings. Decent as backup option if they offer that speed or glove. But Martin offers neither of those. 
      • Ratings: 63, 69, 56/67, 39
  • Designated Hitters
    • Steven Sutcliffe (New York) - Defensively he's close to average 2B with a slight hit to his arm strength so he might not turn double plays on the speedy guys, but that bat is atrocious. There are SO many other bats that could be used as a DH but New York is gunning for that 5th straight #1 overall pick in next year's draft. No wonder the team has a sub .200 expected win percentage. 
      • Ratings: 33, 39, 41/41, 62
  • Starting Pitchers
    • We started our search for the worst SP by starting with all players who have less 70 ratings in Control, vL, & vR; that narrowed it down to just 14 players. Pittsburgh's James Langels & Gene Torres take the cake for worst starters, Chicago has all 5 members of his rotation on the list. That's 5 of the 14 players - or 36% of the list. Andre Justice, Antonio Morton, Chipper Durham, Mike Woodson, and Paul Hill. If Slash's words "...certainly planning to push the envelope on some things..." weren't heard loud and clear before, they sure are now. 
  • Relief Pitchers
    • We decided to omit the Type B relievers because they are generally used less and thus less important to the quality of the team - though they do still matter. 
    • To no surprise, two of the four pitchers who fall in the sub 70 ratings belong to the Chicago Gunslingers. Denard Jones and Sam Ross - both SuA. Though in Ross' defense his Control is actually a 70. But Jones is the worst SuA/LRA in the league. I will say while Chicago's pitchers have awful ratings, their pitch quality is typically higher which is why they haven't been as bad as you'd assume. So...things could be worse. 
Synopsys - New York has the worst position players and Chicago has the worst pitchers. With Pittsburgh right there with both of them. Those teams will easily be 1 - 2 - 3 in next season's draft if things don't change.  

Every player on this list warrants a demotion back to the minors, you could probably find an out of shape blog writer to hit or pitch better than these guys. But then again, that means replacing 90% of the New York ML roster and Chicago's full rotation.  The only position player who I don't consider to be on a bottom 3 team is the Catcher, who plays for a top NL team. New York/Chicago, your open letter might be coming soon. 

Based upon views of others outside of the world, the integrity of Cobbfather is definitely in question ever since New York took rebuilding to the full tanking extreme. Feels like I haven't seen teams this bad since jwinkler's S7 147 Loss. 



Wednesday, July 3, 2024

S60 Location Location Location

Richard Castle - contributing reporter


Coming to a stadium (hopefully) near you, it's time for a realignment in Cobbfather. Let's eliminate the AL and NL, playing in one league with every team adopting the DH. Playoffs would be seeded similar to March Madness with the top 16 teams. First place in each division plus the next 8 teams best ranked teams. The plan might be rejected year after year, but that doesn't stop us from talking about it. Here are our proposed divisions and projected winner for S60.

Northeast: Augusta, Montreal, Hartford, Boston
North: New York, Philadelphia, Washington DC, Dover
East: Chicago, Columbus, Pittsburgh, Buffalo
Central: Colorado Springs, Oklahoma City, Fargo, Minnesota
Southeast: Atlanta, Charleston, Jacksonville, Huntington
South: Mexico City, Houston, Austin, New Orleans
West: Anaheim, Scottsdale, Tucson, Santa Fe
Northwest: Vancouver, Tacoma, Salem, Helena

What do you think? Does this make your division tougher or easier to compete in given the current stance of all-in and rebuilding teams? The North gets interesting as all of those teams currently have a top 10 draft pick this season. From the last time we did this, Houston was in a division with Atlanta but now that's Huntington; what a division that is with Crain, Weiss, and WYW all vying for the AL MVP. We thought about creating a Gulf division of Mexico City, Houston, New Orleans but Jacksonville is on the wrong side of Florida for that to work. Would have been interesting realigning OKC, Austin, Charleston, with current AL powerhouse Atlanta. 

Tuesday, July 2, 2024

S60 Longevity

Jack Torrance - contributing reporter

It's been a few seasons since we've shared this info, just wanted to thank everyone in the league for sticking around. Let's take a look at some of our most seasoned veteran owners. 

Most years in the league - includes the current season and any other seasons the owner was in Cobbfather (under the same account). Thought it would also be fun to list Cobbfather career records. It's great to see that half of our owners have been around for 20+ seasons. Perhaps S70 update I'll be there myself. 

  1. 60 - Houston (5,513-4,045)
  2. 58 - Buffalo (5,080-4,154)
  3. 56 - Atlanta (4,947-3,963)
  4. 48 - Colorado Springs (3,875-3,739)
  5. 35 - Oklahoma City (2,896-2,288)wr
  6. 33 - New York (2,677-2,507)
  7. 32 - Santa Fe (2,726-2,458)
  8. 30 - Montreal (2,471-2,227)
  9. 29 - Chicago (2,198-2,014)
  10. 25 - Helena (1,989-1,899), Minnesota (2,043-1,845)
  11. 24 - Charleston (2,019-1,707)
  12. 23 - Columbus (1,620-1,620), Austin (1,412-1,828)
  13. 22 - Vancouver (1,474-1,604)
  14. 21 - Dover (1,292-1,624)
  15. 18 - Philadelphia (1,395-1,359)
  16. 17 - Pittsburgh (1,202-1,390)
  17. 15 - New Orleans (997-947) - had a different account in the early years
  18. 13 - Huntington (998-946), Anaheim (857-1,087)
  19. 12 - Hartford (1,037-745), Scottsdale (890-869)
  20. 10 - Tacoma (592-866), Salem (681-777), Boston (710-748)
  21. 8 - Augusta (497-637), Mexico City (482-652)
  22. 7 - Tucson (430-380)
  23. 5 - Washington DC (337-473), Jacksonville (323-325)
  24. 1 - Fargo (0-0)

Friday, June 14, 2024

S60 Parks

 Jack Torrance - contributing reporter

With one relocation and a few new teams, let's take a look at the parks that make up Cobbfather. First we'll break them into Hitter, Neutral, and Pitcher parks by using their Park Factors. Bold are last year's playoff teams. Tokyo was not listed as they've changed ownership and parks. 
Pitcher Parks - below 0.970
  • Tacoma - 0.793
  • Oklahoma City - 0.843
  • Anaheim - 0.941
  • Augusta - 0.904
  • Atlanta - 0.950
  • Buffalo - 0.953
  • Charleston - 0.956
  • Mexico City - 0.956
  • Jacksonville - 0.957
Neutral Parks 
  • Columbus - 0.991
  • Chicago - 0.993
  • Colorado Springs - 1.000
  • Pittsburgh - 1.000
  • New York - 1.004
  • Washington DC - 1.004
  • Houston - 1.006
  • Philadelphia - 1.010
  • Minnesota - 1.022
Hitter Parks - above 1.030
  • Vancouver - 1.035
  • Helena - 1.041
  • Fargo - 1.041
    • New Owner, was Milwaukee - 0.990
  • Salem - 1.043
  • Dover - 1.054
  • New Orleans - 1.069
  • Austin - 1.072
  • Montreal - 1.074
  • Boston - 1.111
  • Scottsdale- 1.119
    • New Owner, was Tokyo - 1.280
  • Huntington - 1.134
  • Hartford - 1.134
  • Tucson - 1.194
    • Relocation from Salt Lake City - 1.056
  • Santa Fe - 1.332

Count them, per last year's ratings the top 4 hitting parks all made the playoffs. And 4 of the top pitcher parks made the playoffs. Houston, Minnesota, and Helena were the only playoff teams closer to neutral; though all still favored hitters.